TODAYRead today's current affairs →
YouTubeInstagram
Tathyo
JobsCurrent AffairsInternational RelationsPolityEconomyEducationStore
अ हिंदीSubscribe

The week's essentials, straight to your inbox

Top explainers, current affairs revision and new job alerts. No spam.

Tathyo

Current affairs, international relations, education and govt jobs — explained simply and in depth.

CategoriesCurrent AffairsInternational RelationsPolityEconomyEducationScience & Tech
ExploreSarkari JobsResultsAdmit CardStore
TathyoAboutContactPrivacy PolicyDisclaimerहिंदी संस्करण
© 2026 Tathyo. All rights reserved.RSS
Home/Polity
Polity

The Collegium System Explained: How Judges Are Appointed, the Four Judges Cases, NJAC and Reforms

How judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts are appointed: Articles 124 and 217, the four Judges Cases, the striking down of the NJAC in 2015, the Memorandum of Procedure and reform proposals.

Ankit KumarAnkit Kumar · Founder & Editor, Tathyo19 Nov 2026 · 6 min read
In this article1. Why in the news?2. Background3. Key facts/provisions4. Significance5. Challenges6. Way forward7. Facts for Prelims8. Mains practice question9. FAQs10. Sources

Why in the news?

Appointments of judges to the Supreme Court and High Courts, and delays in clearing collegium recommendations, regularly feature in public debate and parliamentary questions. With a large number of vacancies in High Courts and questions about transparency and diversity, the collegium system remains a core topic for GS Paper II. This explainer sets out how the system works, how it evolved and the main reform proposals.

Background

Constitutional provisions:

  • Article 124(2): Supreme Court judges are appointed by the President after consultation with such judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts as the President deems necessary; for judges other than the Chief Justice, the Chief Justice of India (CJI) must always be consulted.
  • Article 217: High Court judges are appointed by the President after consultation with the CJI, the Governor of the State and the Chief Justice of that High Court.
  • Article 222: Transfer of judges between High Courts.

The word "collegium" does not appear in the Constitution. The system grew out of three Supreme Court judgments.

The Judges Cases:

Case Holding
First Judges Case – S.P. Gupta v. Union of India (1981) "Consultation" does not mean "concurrence"; the executive had primacy
Second Judges Case – Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India (1993) Reversed the 1981 view; gave primacy to the judiciary, with the CJI acting in consultation with senior judges
Third Judges Case – In re Special Reference No. 1 of 1998 Defined the collegium: for the Supreme Court, the CJI and four senior-most judges; for High Courts, the CJI and two senior-most judges
Fourth Judges Case – SCAORA v. Union of India (2015) Struck down the 99th Constitutional Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act, 2014 by a 4:1 majority, reviving the collegium

Key facts/provisions

How appointments work today:

Stage Supreme Court High Courts
Who recommends SC collegium (CJI + 4 senior-most judges) Proposal starts with the HC collegium (Chief Justice + 2 senior-most judges); considered by the SC collegium (CJI + 2 senior-most)
Government role Intelligence Bureau inputs; Law Ministry processes the file; can return a name once for reconsideration Same, with views of the State government and Governor
If reiterated A reiterated recommendation is binding on the government Same
Procedure Guided by the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) Same
  • The NJAC (struck down in 2015) would have included the CJI, two senior-most SC judges, the Union Law Minister and two eminent persons.
  • The Supreme Court has published collegium resolutions on its website since 2017, as a step towards transparency.

Significance

  • Judicial independence: The collegium shields appointments from executive pressure, which the Supreme Court sees as part of the basic structure.
  • Expert assessment: Judges are well placed to assess the legal ability of candidates.
  • Separation of powers: It reduces the risk of a government appointing judges who may later decide cases involving it.

Challenges

  • Opacity: There are no published criteria for selection, and deliberations are not public.
  • Nepotism concerns: Critics allege a "judges appointing judges" system favours familiar names.
  • Diversity: Representation of women, SC/ST/OBC and minority communities in higher judiciary remains low.
  • Delays: Recommendations are sometimes kept pending by the government, and the MoP remains unfinalised after years of discussion.
  • Vacancies: High Courts often function with a substantial number of vacant posts, adding to pendency.

Way forward

  • Finalise a revised Memorandum of Procedure with clear timelines for both the collegium and the government.
  • Publish objective criteria and reasons for selection and rejection.
  • Set up a permanent secretariat to maintain data on eligible candidates.
  • Encourage diversity through broader consultation.
  • Any future reform should preserve judicial primacy, as required by the 2015 judgment.

Facts for Prelims

  • Article 124(2): appointment of SC judges; Article 217: HC judges; Article 222: transfers.
  • First Judges Case 1981; Second 1993; Third 1998; Fourth 2015.
  • SC collegium: CJI + 4 senior-most judges.
  • 99th Amendment Act, 2014 and NJAC Act, 2014 struck down in October 2015 (4:1).
  • Appointment procedure governed by the Memorandum of Procedure.

Mains practice question

"The collegium system protects judicial independence but at the cost of transparency and accountability." Critically examine, and suggest reforms that respect the basic structure. (250 words)

FAQs

Is the collegium system mentioned in the Constitution?

No. It evolved through Supreme Court judgments, mainly the Second Judges Case (1993) and the Third Judges Case (1998).

Who are the members of the Supreme Court collegium?

The Chief Justice of India and the four senior-most judges of the Supreme Court.

Why was the NJAC struck down?

In October 2015, the Supreme Court held by a 4:1 majority that the NJAC, which gave the executive a role equal to the judiciary, violated judicial independence, a part of the basic structure.

Can the government reject a collegium recommendation?

It can return a name once for reconsideration. If the collegium reiterates the name, the recommendation is binding.

Sources

  • Legislative Department – Constitution of India (Articles 124, 217, 222)
  • Department of Justice – Appointment of judges
  • Supreme Court of India – official website (collegium resolutions)
  • PRS Legislative Research
#NJAC 99th Amendment#Second Judges Case#Memorandum of Procedure#judicial independence#UPSC polity
Ankit Kumar
AuthorAnkit KumarFounder & Editor, Tathyo

Ankit Kumar is the founder and editor of Tathyo. He works with BPSC and UPSC aspirants at GS Hub, Patna. At Tathyo, he oversees fact-checking so every article is exam-relevant and based on official sources.

Read also

राजव्यवस्था
Polity

Census 2027 Phase II: Self-Enumeration Begins; Bihar to Self-Enumerate from 10 January and Count Door-to-Door from 25 January

Self-enumeration for Census 2027 began on 16 November 2026 in Goa, Punjab, UP and non-snow-bound Uttarakhand. In Bihar, self-enumeration will run from 10–24 January and house-to-house counting from 25 January to 28 February 2027.

Ankit Kumar · 7 min · 19 Nov 2026
राजव्यवस्था
Polity

Article 356 and President's Rule: Provisions, the Bommai Judgment and the 2005 Bihar Case

An explainer on President's Rule under Article 356: approval and duration, 44th Amendment safeguards, S.R. Bommai (1994), and Rameshwar Prasad (2006) on the 2005 dissolution of the Bihar Assembly.

Ankit Kumar · 6 min · 19 Nov 2026
राजव्यवस्था
Polity

Fast Track Special Courts Scheme Extended to 2031: 850 Courts, Rs 3,788 Crore and the Nirbhaya Fund

On 4 November 2026, the Union Cabinet extended the Fast Track Special Courts scheme for rape and POCSO cases from 1 April 2026 to 31 March 2031, with an outlay of about Rs 3,788 crore and a target of 850 courts.

Ankit Kumar · 6 min · 19 Nov 2026