Governor's Assent to Bills: Articles 200–201 and the Supreme Court's Opinion on the Presidential Reference
In its 20 November 2025 advisory opinion, the Supreme Court held that courts cannot impose timelines on Governors and that there is no 'deemed assent', while allowing a limited direction in cases of prolonged inaction.
Why in the news?
Disputes between State governments and Governors over pending Bills remain a recurring theme in Indian federalism. The constitutional position is now shaped by the Supreme Court's advisory opinion of 20 November 2025 in the Presidential Reference under Article 143 on the powers of Governors and the President over State Bills. This explainer covers Articles 200 and 201, the 2025 opinion, and what it means for Centre–State relations.
Background
- Article 200 (Governor): When a Bill passed by the State Legislature is presented, the Governor may (a) give assent, (b) withhold assent, or (c) reserve the Bill for the President. Under the first proviso, a non-Money Bill may be returned "as soon as possible" with a message for reconsideration; if the House passes it again, the Governor "shall not withhold assent".
- Article 201 (President): For a reserved Bill, the President declares assent or withholds it, and may direct the Governor to return a non-Money Bill to the House for reconsideration.
- No time limit: Neither Article lays down a fixed time limit.
- Tamil Nadu case (April 2025): In State of Tamil Nadu v. Governor of Tamil Nadu (8 April 2025), a two-judge bench set timelines for Governors and the President and, using Article 142, treated ten long-pending Bills as having received assent ("deemed assent").
- The Reference: In May 2025, President Droupadi Murmu referred 14 questions to the Supreme Court under Article 143 on these issues.
Key facts/provisions
Bench: Chief Justice B.R. Gavai and Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, P.S. Narasimha and A.S. Chandurkar; opinion delivered on 20 November 2025.
| Issue | Supreme Court's opinion |
|---|---|
| Governor's options | Only three: assent, withhold assent, or reserve for the President. If assent is withheld, the Bill must be returned to the Legislature — the Governor cannot simply sit on it |
| Discretion | The Governor has discretion under Article 200 and is not always bound by the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers in this matter |
| Timelines | Courts cannot impose fixed timelines on Governors or the President, as the Constitution has none |
| Deemed assent | There is no concept of "deemed assent"; Article 142 cannot be used to substitute the constitutional role of the Governor or the President |
| Judicial review | Decisions on merits are not justiciable, but in cases of prolonged, unexplained and indefinite inaction, a court can issue a limited mandamus asking the Governor to decide within a reasonable time |
| Article 361 | The Governor has personal immunity, but this does not bar the limited review of prolonged inaction |
| Reference to SC | The President need not seek the Court's opinion every time a Bill is reserved |
| Pre-enactment review | Bills cannot be challenged in court before they become law |
Two of the 14 questions (Q12 and Q14) were returned unanswered as not relevant.
Significance
1. Separation of powers. The opinion holds that the judiciary cannot rewrite the Constitution by adding timelines or deeming assent — that would be taking over executive functions.
2. Check on inaction. At the same time, it rejects the idea that a Governor can keep a Bill pending forever. The "withhold must mean return" principle and limited mandamus give States a remedy.
3. Federal balance. The Governor is a link between the Centre and the States. Clarity on Article 200 reduces room for conflict, though the absence of timelines may still allow delays.
4. Advisory jurisdiction. The case shows how Article 143 is used: an opinion of the Court is advisory and not a judgment in a dispute, though it carries great persuasive weight.
Challenges
- "Reasonable time" is vague: Without a fixed deadline, disputes over what counts as unreasonable delay may return to court.
- Discretion vs. democracy: Wide discretion for an appointed Governor can clash with the will of an elected Legislature.
- Political friction: Opposition-ruled States have accused Governors of acting on the Centre's behalf.
Way forward
- The Sarkaria Commission (1988) and Punchhi Commission (2010) recommended that Governors decide on Bills within a reasonable, defined period; these can guide conventions.
- Parliament could consider a constitutional amendment if a time limit is considered necessary.
- Regular consultation between Raj Bhavans and State governments can reduce disputes.
Facts for Prelims
- Article 200: Governor's options on State Bills.
- Article 201: Bills reserved for the President.
- Article 143: President may seek the Supreme Court's advisory opinion.
- Article 361: Protection of the President and Governors.
- Presidential Reference opinion: 20 November 2025, five-judge bench headed by CJI B.R. Gavai.
- Earlier ruling: State of Tamil Nadu v. Governor of Tamil Nadu, 8 April 2025 (two judges).
Mains practice question
"The Supreme Court's 2025 advisory opinion strikes a balance between gubernatorial discretion and legislative supremacy." Critically analyse. (250 words)
FAQs
What are the Governor's options under Article 200?
The Governor can give assent, withhold assent (and then return the Bill to the Legislature), or reserve the Bill for the President's consideration.
Can courts fix a time limit for Governors to act on Bills?
No. In its 20 November 2025 opinion, the Supreme Court said courts cannot impose fixed timelines, but they can issue a limited direction in cases of prolonged and unexplained inaction.
What is "deemed assent"?
It is the idea that a Bill is treated as having received assent if the Governor does not act within a time limit. The Supreme Court held that the Constitution has no such concept and Article 142 cannot be used to create it.
Is an advisory opinion under Article 143 binding?
An advisory opinion is not a judgment in a dispute between parties, but it carries strong persuasive and practical authority and is generally followed.
Sources
- Legislative Department – Constitution of India (Articles 143, 200, 201, 361)
- Supreme Court of India (official website)
- LiveLaw – No timelines for Governors/President, no deemed assent: Supreme Court in Presidential Reference (20 Nov 2025)
- Supreme Court Observer – Presidential Reference on powers of the Governor and President
- Inter-State Council Secretariat – Sarkaria and Punchhi Commission reports

Ankit Kumar is the founder and editor of Tathyo. He works with BPSC and UPSC aspirants at GS Hub, Patna. At Tathyo, he oversees fact-checking so every article is exam-relevant and based on official sources.
Read also
Census 2027 Phase II: Self-Enumeration Begins; Bihar to Self-Enumerate from 10 January and Count Door-to-Door from 25 January
Self-enumeration for Census 2027 began on 16 November 2026 in Goa, Punjab, UP and non-snow-bound Uttarakhand. In Bihar, self-enumeration will run from 10–24 January and house-to-house counting from 25 January to 28 February 2027.
Article 356 and President's Rule: Provisions, the Bommai Judgment and the 2005 Bihar Case
An explainer on President's Rule under Article 356: approval and duration, 44th Amendment safeguards, S.R. Bommai (1994), and Rameshwar Prasad (2006) on the 2005 dissolution of the Bihar Assembly.
Fast Track Special Courts Scheme Extended to 2031: 850 Courts, Rs 3,788 Crore and the Nirbhaya Fund
On 4 November 2026, the Union Cabinet extended the Fast Track Special Courts scheme for rape and POCSO cases from 1 April 2026 to 31 March 2031, with an outlay of about Rs 3,788 crore and a target of 850 courts.